Tuesday, October 23, 2012

FIAE chapters 7, 8, 9, 10

          Chapters 7, 8, 9 and 10 of Fair Isn’t Always Equal are all about grading. Chapter 7 focuses on defining the concept of grading. According to Wormeli, “There are some aspects of teaching that we keep in cages in hopes they will never escape. Collectively, they are the “elephant in the room” that everyone can see but no one mentions for fear of reprisals. Grading practices are often this elephant” (FIAE pg 89). As a student, grades drove my education. My parents focused primarily on my grades, like they were evidence that I learned things. It didn’t matter if I truly grasped the concept; as long as the grades were there everything was ok. It drove me nuts. I have often questioned how they can put a number or a time frame on learning. If a student has learned it, isn’t that enough? Then there’s the ever so annoying methods of grading that teachers don’t realize actually hurts instead of helps. For example the red pen correcting and frowny faces next to wrong answers. Chapter 8 focuses on the big question of why when it comes to grading, and where attendance, behavior and effort come in to play. According to Wormeli, there are 6 key reasons why teachers grade; to document student and teacher progress, to provide feedback to the student and family, to inform instructional decisions, to motivate students, to punish students and to sort students. The first three reasons are why grades can work, it provides feedback on progression of learning. The last three reasons are why grades can work against what we want as teachers. If everything becomes about getting the grades, how can we encourage them to learn in real life, when things aren’t on a grade scale? In my opinion, grades are the ultimate rewards system- which the MEL model tells us to avoid. I am more in support of switching to a content mastery scale and doing away with grades like many elementary and middle schools are doing. Chapter 9 discusses ten things to avoid in the practice of differentiation when it comes to assessment and grading. One of the most interesting points this chapter mentions is to avoid penalizing students’ multiple attempts at mastery. I found this quite interesting because my mentor teacher does the opposite of that- in fact he doesn’t let students retry anything at all. Personally, I like the idea of allowing redos- but to make it fair I would only allow a certain number of redos because I don’t want kids thinking they can get away with purposefully not studying. As a student, wife, and part time employee, I know life happens and sometimes it is hard to get things done. That is why I often hold the philosophy of the golden rule. I would love it if I could have that breathing room for mistakes, which as stressful as my life is, happens often. So, I want to give my students that same courtesy that I would like teachers to give to me. We are all human, why can’t we bear with each other? 

No comments:

Post a Comment