CIA
Tuesday, November 27, 2012
FIAE 11,12,13,14
These chapters focus on grading and the issues that come along with that daunting task. One part of chapter 11 really made sense to me, it talks about the difference between recording a 60 or a zero in the grading book. Averaging grades is hard (and ineffective) enough as it is- but throwing a zero in the mix is often a devastating blow to their grade and one that is extremely difficult to climb out of. There is no difference between a failing grade of zero and a failing grade of 60, with the exception of the 60 being more average friendly and reflecting the real mastery level of a student. The section on grading late work really helped me because I am so used to the “no exception, late work is a zero” philosophy that most of my previous teachers and professors swear by. In my opinion, these methods stem from selfishness on the part of the teacher. I think it is unfair for the teacher to assume that the student doesn’t have a life outside of school. Many high school students have to work, or take care of their siblings. I am married and work part time as well as go to school full time, so I know how tough it can be to get your work in on time. If things happen and a student can’t get the work in, I’d use the golden rule and give them the benefit of the doubt. As a teacher, I’d much rather give the student extra time to do the assignment right then have them fling a wad of crap at a paper and hand it in just to make the deadline. I know there is a point to deadlines, because the real world is full of them- but as a teacher, it is extremely important to assign realistic deadlines. As far as grading scales go, I really like the 4.0 scale because it is easy to follow and perfect for projects. I want my class to be project-based with little to no tests because tests open up test anxiety and that is something that I am strongly against. I also like to dress up my categories for rubrics to add in a little history. For my Civil War unit I use military ranks for my grade categories. Report Cards are one of the hardest, and potentially misleading, parts of being a teacher. In chapter 14, the author talks about the dual approach report cards that reflect both the grade as well as personal progress of the student. Sure, the student may have gotten a B, but with the number after it to tell parents that they have made tremendous progress- it is a comforting note to them that their child is succeeding.
Tuesday, October 23, 2012
FIAE chapters 7, 8, 9, 10
Chapters
7, 8, 9 and 10 of Fair Isn’t Always Equal are all about grading. Chapter
7 focuses on defining the concept of grading. According to Wormeli, “There are
some aspects of teaching that we keep in cages in hopes they will never escape.
Collectively, they are the “elephant in the room” that everyone can see but no
one mentions for fear of reprisals. Grading practices are often this elephant”
(FIAE pg 89). As a student, grades drove my education. My parents focused
primarily on my grades, like they were evidence that I learned things. It
didn’t matter if I truly grasped the concept; as long as the grades were there
everything was ok. It drove me nuts. I have often questioned how they can put a
number or a time frame on learning. If a student has learned it, isn’t that
enough? Then there’s the ever so annoying methods of grading that teachers
don’t realize actually hurts instead of helps. For example the red pen
correcting and frowny faces next to wrong answers. Chapter 8 focuses on the big
question of why when it comes to grading, and where attendance, behavior and
effort come in to play. According to Wormeli, there are 6 key reasons why teachers
grade; to document student and teacher progress, to provide feedback to the
student and family, to inform instructional decisions, to motivate students, to
punish students and to sort students. The first three reasons are why grades
can work, it provides feedback on progression of learning. The last three
reasons are why grades can work against what we want as teachers. If everything
becomes about getting the grades, how can we encourage them to learn in real
life, when things aren’t on a grade scale? In my opinion, grades are the
ultimate rewards system- which the MEL model tells us to avoid. I am more in
support of switching to a content mastery scale and doing away with grades like
many elementary and middle schools are doing. Chapter 9 discusses ten things to
avoid in the practice of differentiation when it comes to assessment and
grading. One of the most interesting points this chapter mentions is to avoid
penalizing students’ multiple attempts at mastery. I found this quite
interesting because my mentor teacher does the opposite of that- in fact he doesn’t
let students retry anything at all. Personally, I like the idea of allowing
redos- but to make it fair I would only allow a certain number of redos because
I don’t want kids thinking they can get away with purposefully not studying. As
a student, wife, and part time employee, I know life happens and sometimes it is
hard to get things done. That is why I often hold the philosophy of the golden
rule. I would love it if I could have that breathing room for mistakes, which
as stressful as my life is, happens often. So, I want to give my
students that same courtesy that I would like teachers to give to me. We are
all human, why can’t we bear with each other?
Sunday, October 21, 2012
UbD Chapter 8, MI Chapters 8, 11, 12
Chapter 8 of UbD focuses on grading
and how to grade well as well as how to report grades. There are 6 principles
that the book refers to as essential to effective grading and reporting. One principle
is that you should have clear standards and goals. I think the most effective
way to get these specified standards and goals across is to use rubrics because
they lay everything out in a clear and organized way if done correctly. The
chapter also touches upon the notion that grading and assessment isn’t necessarily
the same thing. Assessment is merely collecting information about a student’s
progress and grading is an end judgment on their achievement. Another important
point is not to base grades on averages; the reasoning behind this is that if
the point of education is to learn- it is unfair to put a time frame on it.
This ties in nicely with the concept mastery that many schools are now implementing.
Chapter 8
focuses on the classroom management aspect in relation to the MI theory. I
found the getting students attention section a bit silly because, at least the
way I read and understood it, to do all of those things at the same time would
just cause distraction in my opinion, it might be better to use every strategy
at least once per day. I really liked the section in forming groups with
different intelligences, that way more ways of thinking can be brought into the
group and someone’s strengths can account for another’s weaknesses.
Chapter 11 centers around the MI theory in relation to special education. The
author makes a great point; he says “Over the history of the Special Education
movement in the United States, educators have had a disturbing tendency to work
from a deficit paradigm- focusing on what students can’t do- in an attempt to
help students succeed in school” (MI pg 149). This is something that I feel
strongly about because my husband was placed in a special education because of
his ADD. What resulted was teachers “dumbing down” material rather than
focusing on relating the material to what he is talented at like auto mechanics.
I think that the MI model would benefit the special education system greatly. Chapter
12 focuses on using MI to develop thinking strategies. Armstrong says “How
students think has almost become more important than what they think about” (MI
pg 161). The first section within this chapter deals with memory and it gives
an 8 way example of how to help memory, the example it uses is in spelling
words. One way for the bodily-kinesthetic learner to practice spelling words is
by using things like modeling clay or using bodily movements to display things
like syllables. The chapter also shows how to use MI in conjunction with blooms
taxonomy to help students achieve better thinking skills.
Chapters 7,9,13,14 MI
Multiple Intelligences in the Classroom is probably my most favorite book out of the readings that we have done thus far. I love the concept that pushes away from picking kids out as “smart” or “dumb” because those conventional definitions of intelligence are really frustrating to me. Chapter 7 focuses on the idea of classroom “ecology”, or the physical appearance of your classroom setup to meet the needs of every student. For example, a classroom with no windows will not engage a naturalist intelligence or a classroom with no pictures will not engage a visual learner. It would be difficult to choose a setup that fits all learners, but sometimes having stations if there is choice time will help meet the students’ needs. Chapter 8 focuses on the classroom management aspect in relation to the MI theory. I found the getting students attention section a bit silly because, at least the way I read and understood it, to do all of those things at the same time would just cause distraction in my opinion, it might be better to use every strategy at least once per day. I really liked the section in forming groups with different intelligences, that way more ways of thinking can be brought into the group and someone’s strengths can account for another’s weaknesses.
Chapter 13 was a miscellaneous chapter that covered a few applications of the MI theory that didn’t fit in another section. The first section was about computer technology and how you can suit it to fit every need. It has a huge graph with computer activities that can be applied to every intelligence in the classroom. For example, you can use animation programs for the visual learner or things like GarageBand for musical learners. Another section in the misc. chapter was about cultural diversity and how the MIs are cross cultural. According to the book; “every culture has and uses all 8 intelligences” (Page 177). The last section dealt with how to guide students to choose their career based on their MIs. For example a linguistic learner might choose to be a librarian or journalist, and an intrapersonal learner might consider a career in psychology. Chapter 14 talks about the author’s belief in a sort of semi-intelligence known as the existential intelligence. This ninth intelligence involves thinking deeply and exploring big ideas and concepts. I personally think that this might link with intrapersonal intelligence, but it may be just broad enough to get its own title. It is important for every teacher to practice this intelligence because we are lifelong learners and thinkers, so we must think in a broad scope of directions and constantly ask ourselves big questions.
Chapter 13 was a miscellaneous chapter that covered a few applications of the MI theory that didn’t fit in another section. The first section was about computer technology and how you can suit it to fit every need. It has a huge graph with computer activities that can be applied to every intelligence in the classroom. For example, you can use animation programs for the visual learner or things like GarageBand for musical learners. Another section in the misc. chapter was about cultural diversity and how the MIs are cross cultural. According to the book; “every culture has and uses all 8 intelligences” (Page 177). The last section dealt with how to guide students to choose their career based on their MIs. For example a linguistic learner might choose to be a librarian or journalist, and an intrapersonal learner might consider a career in psychology. Chapter 14 talks about the author’s belief in a sort of semi-intelligence known as the existential intelligence. This ninth intelligence involves thinking deeply and exploring big ideas and concepts. I personally think that this might link with intrapersonal intelligence, but it may be just broad enough to get its own title. It is important for every teacher to practice this intelligence because we are lifelong learners and thinkers, so we must think in a broad scope of directions and constantly ask ourselves big questions.
Tuesday, October 16, 2012
MI Chapter 5,6 & UbD Chapter 6,7
These chapters focus on preparing
the classroom for a diverse group of learners. The state of Maine is a little
behind the ethnicity curve, but slowly we are starting to see more ethnically and
culturally diverse population. Chapter 5 of the MI book discusses how to
develop your tools of teaching to suit the needs of the multiple intelligences,
especially when developing curriculum. It gives many ways to teach to each type
of learner. For example one suggestion for the ever-so tricky
bodily-kinesthetic learner, the book suggests things like field trips,
manipulatives, and charades. For the visual learner it suggests videos,
pictures and 3d construction kit. Chapter 6 of MI discusses strategies to teach
all of the multiple intelligences. One suggestion that the book made for
logical intelligent people is Socratic Seminars. I have recently become aware of
this concept as a part of my mentor teacher’s class. He often uses these series
of question based discussion to gauge his students’ views on a topic, I find it
fascinating and hope to use this method in my classroom someday. Another suggestion
the book makes for musical learners is making discographies. This is especially
prevalent in social studies because all throughout history, music has been an
ever changing medium and many youth were inspired by the music of their times.
In the history classroom, you can have your musical learner compile a music CD
of important music of a certain era and listen to it to set the mood for the
day.
Chapter 6 and 7 of Ubd talks about
how to be aware of your diverse learning environment and how to teach accordingly.
In the beginning of chapter 6, it analyzes four essential questions in relation
to academically diverse students. One
big question to ask yourself as a teacher is who are my students? This is so
important as an educator because kids want to know that you care about both
their learning styles and the kids themselves. The first thing a teacher should
do, in my opinion, is an MI activity so they can learn first thing what kind of
mixture they are dealing with. Second,
the educator must reflect upon the diverse learning group and ask what is
important for this group to learn? Kids won’t respond well to material that
they feel is irrelevant to their life. Many kids hate history for this reason,
but they don’t realize is that the actions of the past dictate how we live
today. If the Civil War hadn’t happened or if the Confederacy won, we might
even still have slavery today. Third is the question of how to teach this group
so they all benefit from the class and learn more about the content area. In
order to have a successful classroom, the teacher must address every student’s
needs. By developing your lesson plans to include different learning styles,
the whole class will benefit. Fourth is how to properly check for knowledge and
mastery skills. You can do this by simply holding discussions with your class
to get a feel for what they have understood and asking essential questions to
push them to reflect on their new-found knowledge.
Saturday, October 13, 2012
Fair Isn't Always Equal Chapter 6
I’m not entirely sure why this chapter is prevalent to what
we are learning at this stage of our teaching careers, since we aren’t even
going to talk about making tests. But, regardless this chapter had different
tips in how to write good test questions so that our students won’t be so
anxious and nerved up when it comes test time. Some examples of these tips are;
use a variety of questions/prompts, double recording of test responses, make
prompts clear.
Some
methods in this chapter really resonated with me because they addressed what
exactly made me hate some teachers’ tests. The section entitled “Avoid
Confusing Negatives” made me say Yes! I always hated when teachers would word
questions in confusing negatives in questions like “Which of these is not a negative
impact on society during the Civil War”. Questions like this would annoy me so
bad! I could never figure them out and often got confused on the correct
answer. Another thing I always hated was addressed in the very beginning; I
always hated it when the question started with “Pick the most true answer”. It was like those questions are built to trick
people! One of my favorite things that I want to incorporate is fun test
questions that allow students to be creative. For example I love history
simulation, so instead of boring essay questions I’d have them write a journal
entry from someone in that time period. You still get the information you are
looking for, but it is exponentially more entertaining for both the teacher and
the student.
Fair Isn't Always Equal Chapter 5
This chapter focuses on the idea of tiering assessments,
which separates the class based on their content mastery levels. The levels are
then specialized to fit the learning needs of these students. The students who
understand quicker are given more challenging assignments to master. Students
who are learning at a normal pace can keep going at that pace and the students
who are struggling can receive more instruction and an easier-to-understand
explanation of the topic.
Tiering
assessment is a somewhat new idea to me, I have briefly heard of it but this
chapter went into it more and fully explained the idea. It is essentially a
different way to create a differentiated instruction style. However, I am unsure of whether I like it. The biggest thing
that I am confused on is if tiering assessment is as good as the 8 way MI
assessment mentioned in chapter 10 of the MI book. In 8th grade I
was introduced to RAFT assignments and found it incredibly boring because it
was just writing- it didn’t target my visual learning style and desire for
creativity, I couldn’t create anything with it so I was just uninterested. It
seems to me that tiering is functioning on the conventional smart-dumb scale
instead of aiming for the idea of different types of learning. I suppose it is
good to keep in mind the three paces when creating lessons, but to me it just
doesn’t seem as effective as other methods. To me it is like offering different
chocolate bars to someone who doesn’t like chocolate- you can explain things as
simply as you want, but if you don’t put it into perspective of how they learn
best, it just won’t be as inspirational.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)